Expectations and Outcomes for Business Change: Why the Gap?

We explore the reasons behind this mismatch and offer recommendations for improving success rates. If you’re already worried, why not take our Free 2-minute Change Health Check?

Introduction

Organisations frequently engage in M&A, integration, transformation, and change initiatives to drive growth and maintain competitiveness. However, a significant gap often exists between C-suite expectations and the actual results of these endeavours.

C-Suite Confidence Levels in Change

Research indicates that C-suite executives generally maintain high confidence in their organisation’s ability to successfully execute M&A, integration, and transformation initiatives:

• Accenture reports that 96% of global organisations plan to invest more than 5% of their total revenues in change initiatives over the next three years.

Actual Results: Expectations and outcomes for business change

Despite high confidence levels, there’s usually a sizeable gap between expectations and outcomes for business change amongst the C-suite:

• McKinsey & Company research confirms that companies regularly pursuing moderately-sized M&A deliver better shareholder returns than those that don’t. However, many acquisitions still fail to meet expectations.
• Data from 1,400 M&A deals collected by Mercer concluded that cultural issues were the reason 30% of them failed to meet their financial targets.
• Only 30% of C-suite leaders are confident in their change capabilities, despite 100% of them anticipating changes to their workforce.
• A study by Harvard Business Review found that only 40% of respondents experienced significant improvements from digital transformation initiatives.

Reasons for the Mismatch

Several factors contribute to the gap between expectations and outcomes for Business Change amongst the C-suite:

1. Incomplete or Poorly-Defined Strategy

Many organisations fail to develop a comprehensive change management strategy that addresses both the “what” and “how” of the transformation. This lack of strategic planning can lead to short-term tactical decisions that undermine long-term goals.

2. Cultural Misalignment

Cultural issues are often underestimated or overlooked in M&A and transformation initiatives. Misalignment between two company cultures is a prominent factor in acquisition failure. Organisations that fail to address cultural integration risk escalating conflicting priorities and confusion across newly combined teams.

3. Inadequate Resources and Support

Resource constraints, such as insufficient budgets or understaffing, can sabotage execution. Without the necessary resources and support from leadership, teams struggle to accomplish their tasks effectively.

4. Resistance to Change

Change initiatives often face resistance from employees who are comfortable with the status quo. Failure to address this resistance through effective communication and employee engagement can lead to delays, reduced morale, and even active sabotage of the strategy.

5. Lack of Effective Communication

Poor communication during change initiatives can lead to misunderstandings, diminished trust, and a loss of momentum. Many leaders underestimate the need for ongoing communication after the initial announcement of a change.

6. Unrealistic Expectations

C-suite executives often underestimate the time and resources required for successful change initiatives while overestimating the potential results, leading to unfounded confidence. This mismatch in expectations can lead to premature judgments of failure or abandonment of initiatives before they have a chance to succeed.

7. Inadequate Monitoring and Adaptation

Many organisations fail to establish robust systems for monitoring progress and adapting strategies as needed. Without clear KPIs and regular reporting mechanisms, it becomes difficult to steer initiatives toward success and make timely adjustments.

8. Technology-Centric Approach

Some organisations focus too heavily on implementing new technologies without first analysing their specific challenges and objectives. This technology-centric approach can lead to inefficiencies and poor integration with existing systems and processes.

9. Siloed Implementation

Change initiatives are often carried out in isolation within specific departments, lacking an overall strategic vision. This siloed approach can result in inefficiencies, friction between systems, and higher maintenance costs.

10. Failure to Create and Celebrate Short-Term Wins

Organisations that don’t build achievable short-term goals into their strategic plans risk losing momentum and enthusiasm for change initiatives. Celebrating small victories is crucial for maintaining motivation and demonstrating progress.

Recommendations for Improvement

To bridge the gap between expectations and results, organisations should consider the following strategies:

1. Develop a comprehensive change management strategy that aligns with the organisation’s mission, values, and culture.
2. Prioritise cultural integration in M&A and transformation initiatives.
3. Ensure adequate resources and support from leadership throughout the change process.
4. Implement effective communication strategies that address resistance to change and maintain ongoing engagement.
5. Set realistic expectations and timelines for change initiatives.
6. Establish robust monitoring systems with clear KPIs and regular reporting mechanisms.
7. Balance technology implementation with a focus on business objectives and human factors.
8. Foster cross-functional collaboration and alignment across the organisation.
9. Create and celebrate short-term wins to maintain momentum and demonstrate progress.
10. Invest in building continuous change capabilities within the organisation.

Conclusion: Expectations and outcomes for business change

While C-suite confidence levels in Change, whether M&A, integration, or transformation initiatives remains high, expectations and outcomes are often a long way apart. By understanding the reasons behind this mismatch and implementing strategies to address these challenges, organisations can improve their chances of success in change initiatives.

Worried?

To assess your organisation’s readiness for change and identify areas for improvement, we encourage you to take the Free 2-minute Change Health Check. We can help you to identify and resolve any gap between expectations and outcomes for Business Change.

This quick assessment will provide valuable insights into your current change management processes and help you identify potential areas for enhancement. By taking proactive steps to improve your change management capabilities, you can increase the likelihood of success in your M&A, integration, and transformation initiatives, ultimately bridging the gap between expectations and results.

What’s next?

Follow us on LinkedIn

Contact us for an informal discussion, or book in some time now via our online calendar

Did you know: Mismanaging Change is the number 1 reason CEOs lose their job

Would you like a copy of our Change Management Guide?

Further Useful Links

Would you like our free Change Management Guide?

Want to know more about our services and How we work?

How2-Change Reality Check®

Business Change Training

Business Change Coaching

Business Change Recruitment

Business Change Implementation

Here’s a link to our General FAQs page. We also have specific FAQs for each of our services.